Rubric Design

Main navigation, articulating your assessment values.

Reading, commenting on, and then assigning a grade to a piece of student writing requires intense attention and difficult judgment calls. Some faculty dread “the stack.” Students may share the faculty’s dim view of writing assessment, perceiving it as highly subjective. They wonder why one faculty member values evidence and correctness before all else, while another seeks a vaguely defined originality.

Writing rubrics can help address the concerns of both faculty and students by making writing assessment more efficient, consistent, and public. Whether it is called a grading rubric, a grading sheet, or a scoring guide, a writing assignment rubric lists criteria by which the writing is graded.

Why create a writing rubric?

  • It makes your tacit rhetorical knowledge explicit
  • It articulates community- and discipline-specific standards of excellence
  • It links the grade you give the assignment to the criteria
  • It can make your grading more efficient, consistent, and fair as you can read and comment with your criteria in mind
  • It can help you reverse engineer your course: once you have the rubrics created, you can align your readings, activities, and lectures with the rubrics to set your students up for success
  • It can help your students produce writing that you look forward to reading

How to create a writing rubric

Create a rubric at the same time you create the assignment. It will help you explain to the students what your goals are for the assignment.

  • Consider your purpose: do you need a rubric that addresses the standards for all the writing in the course? Or do you need to address the writing requirements and standards for just one assignment?  Task-specific rubrics are written to help teachers assess individual assignments or genres, whereas generic rubrics are written to help teachers assess multiple assignments.
  • Begin by listing the important qualities of the writing that will be produced in response to a particular assignment. It may be helpful to have several examples of excellent versions of the assignment in front of you: what writing elements do they all have in common? Among other things, these may include features of the argument, such as a main claim or thesis; use and presentation of sources, including visuals; and formatting guidelines such as the requirement of a works cited.
  • Then consider how the criteria will be weighted in grading. Perhaps all criteria are equally important, or perhaps there are two or three that all students must achieve to earn a passing grade. Decide what best fits the class and requirements of the assignment.

Consider involving students in Steps 2 and 3. A class session devoted to developing a rubric can provoke many important discussions about the ways the features of the language serve the purpose of the writing. And when students themselves work to describe the writing they are expected to produce, they are more likely to achieve it.

At this point, you will need to decide if you want to create a holistic or an analytic rubric. There is much debate about these two approaches to assessment.

Comparing Holistic and Analytic Rubrics

Holistic scoring .

Holistic scoring aims to rate overall proficiency in a given student writing sample. It is often used in large-scale writing program assessment and impromptu classroom writing for diagnostic purposes.

General tenets to holistic scoring:

  • Responding to drafts is part of evaluation
  • Responses do not focus on grammar and mechanics during drafting and there is little correction
  • Marginal comments are kept to 2-3 per page with summative comments at end
  • End commentary attends to students’ overall performance across learning objectives as articulated in the assignment
  • Response language aims to foster students’ self-assessment

Holistic rubrics emphasize what students do well and generally increase efficiency; they may also be more valid because scoring includes authentic, personal reaction of the reader. But holistic sores won’t tell a student how they’ve progressed relative to previous assignments and may be rater-dependent, reducing reliability. (For a summary of advantages and disadvantages of holistic scoring, see Becker, 2011, p. 116.)

Here is an example of a partial holistic rubric:

Summary meets all the criteria. The writer understands the article thoroughly. The main points in the article appear in the summary with all main points proportionately developed. The summary should be as comprehensive as possible and should be as comprehensive as possible and should read smoothly, with appropriate transitions between ideas. Sentences should be clear, without vagueness or ambiguity and without grammatical or mechanical errors.

A complete holistic rubric for a research paper (authored by Jonah Willihnganz) can be  downloaded here.

Analytic Scoring

Analytic scoring makes explicit the contribution to the final grade of each element of writing. For example, an instructor may choose to give 30 points for an essay whose ideas are sufficiently complex, that marshals good reasons in support of a thesis, and whose argument is logical; and 20 points for well-constructed sentences and careful copy editing.

General tenets to analytic scoring:

  • Reflect emphases in your teaching and communicate the learning goals for the course
  • Emphasize student performance across criterion, which are established as central to the assignment in advance, usually on an assignment sheet
  • Typically take a quantitative approach, providing a scaled set of points for each criterion
  • Make the analytic framework available to students before they write  

Advantages of an analytic rubric include ease of training raters and improved reliability. Meanwhile, writers often can more easily diagnose the strengths and weaknesses of their work. But analytic rubrics can be time-consuming to produce, and raters may judge the writing holistically anyway. Moreover, many readers believe that writing traits cannot be separated. (For a summary of the advantages and disadvantages of analytic scoring, see Becker, 2011, p. 115.)

For example, a partial analytic rubric for a single trait, “addresses a significant issue”:

  • Excellent: Elegantly establishes the current problem, why it matters, to whom
  • Above Average: Identifies the problem; explains why it matters and to whom
  • Competent: Describes topic but relevance unclear or cursory
  • Developing: Unclear issue and relevance

A  complete analytic rubric for a research paper can be downloaded here.  In WIM courses, this language should be revised to name specific disciplinary conventions.

Whichever type of rubric you write, your goal is to avoid pushing students into prescriptive formulas and limiting thinking (e.g., “each paragraph has five sentences”). By carefully describing the writing you want to read, you give students a clear target, and, as Ed White puts it, “describe the ongoing work of the class” (75).

Writing rubrics contribute meaningfully to the teaching of writing. Think of them as a coaching aide. In class and in conferences, you can use the language of the rubric to help you move past generic statements about what makes good writing good to statements about what constitutes success on the assignment and in the genre or discourse community. The rubric articulates what you are asking students to produce on the page; once that work is accomplished, you can turn your attention to explaining how students can achieve it.

Works Cited

Becker, Anthony.  “Examining Rubrics Used to Measure Writing Performance in U.S. Intensive English Programs.”   The CATESOL Journal  22.1 (2010/2011):113-30. Web.

White, Edward M.  Teaching and Assessing Writing . Proquest Info and Learning, 1985. Print.

Further Resources

CCCC Committee on Assessment. “Writing Assessment: A Position Statement.” November 2006 (Revised March 2009). Conference on College Composition and Communication. Web.

Gallagher, Chris W. “Assess Locally, Validate Globally: Heuristics for Validating Local Writing Assessments.” Writing Program Administration 34.1 (2010): 10-32. Web.

Huot, Brian.  (Re)Articulating Writing Assessment for Teaching and Learning.  Logan: Utah State UP, 2002. Print.

Kelly-Reilly, Diane, and Peggy O’Neil, eds. Journal of Writing Assessment. Web.

McKee, Heidi A., and Dànielle Nicole DeVoss DeVoss, Eds. Digital Writing Assessment & Evaluation. Logan, UT: Computers and Composition Digital Press/Utah State University Press, 2013. Web.

O’Neill, Peggy, Cindy Moore, and Brian Huot.  A Guide to College Writing Assessment . Logan: Utah State UP, 2009. Print.

Sommers, Nancy.  Responding to Student Writers . Macmillan Higher Education, 2013.

Straub, Richard. “Responding, Really Responding to Other Students’ Writing.” The Subject is Writing: Essays by Teachers and Students. Ed. Wendy Bishop. Boynton/Cook, 1999. Web.

White, Edward M., and Cassie A. Wright.  Assigning, Responding, Evaluating: A Writing Teacher’s Guide . 5th ed. Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2015. Print.

Rubric Best Practices, Examples, and Templates

A rubric is a scoring tool that identifies the different criteria relevant to an assignment, assessment, or learning outcome and states the possible levels of achievement in a specific, clear, and objective way. Use rubrics to assess project-based student work including essays, group projects, creative endeavors, and oral presentations.

Rubrics can help instructors communicate expectations to students and assess student work fairly, consistently and efficiently. Rubrics can provide students with informative feedback on their strengths and weaknesses so that they can reflect on their performance and work on areas that need improvement.

How to Get Started

Best practices, moodle how-to guides.

  • Workshop Recording (Fall 2022)
  • Workshop Registration

Step 1: Analyze the assignment

The first step in the rubric creation process is to analyze the assignment or assessment for which you are creating a rubric. To do this, consider the following questions:

  • What is the purpose of the assignment and your feedback? What do you want students to demonstrate through the completion of this assignment (i.e. what are the learning objectives measured by it)? Is it a summative assessment, or will students use the feedback to create an improved product?
  • Does the assignment break down into different or smaller tasks? Are these tasks equally important as the main assignment?
  • What would an “excellent” assignment look like? An “acceptable” assignment? One that still needs major work?
  • How detailed do you want the feedback you give students to be? Do you want/need to give them a grade?

Step 2: Decide what kind of rubric you will use

Types of rubrics: holistic, analytic/descriptive, single-point

Holistic Rubric. A holistic rubric includes all the criteria (such as clarity, organization, mechanics, etc.) to be considered together and included in a single evaluation. With a holistic rubric, the rater or grader assigns a single score based on an overall judgment of the student’s work, using descriptions of each performance level to assign the score.

Advantages of holistic rubrics:

  • Can p lace an emphasis on what learners can demonstrate rather than what they cannot
  • Save grader time by minimizing the number of evaluations to be made for each student
  • Can be used consistently across raters, provided they have all been trained

Disadvantages of holistic rubrics:

  • Provide less specific feedback than analytic/descriptive rubrics
  • Can be difficult to choose a score when a student’s work is at varying levels across the criteria
  • Any weighting of c riteria cannot be indicated in the rubric

Analytic/Descriptive Rubric . An analytic or descriptive rubric often takes the form of a table with the criteria listed in the left column and with levels of performance listed across the top row. Each cell contains a description of what the specified criterion looks like at a given level of performance. Each of the criteria is scored individually.

Advantages of analytic rubrics:

  • Provide detailed feedback on areas of strength or weakness
  • Each criterion can be weighted to reflect its relative importance

Disadvantages of analytic rubrics:

  • More time-consuming to create and use than a holistic rubric
  • May not be used consistently across raters unless the cells are well defined
  • May result in giving less personalized feedback

Single-Point Rubric . A single-point rubric is breaks down the components of an assignment into different criteria, but instead of describing different levels of performance, only the “proficient” level is described. Feedback space is provided for instructors to give individualized comments to help students improve and/or show where they excelled beyond the proficiency descriptors.

Advantages of single-point rubrics:

  • Easier to create than an analytic/descriptive rubric
  • Perhaps more likely that students will read the descriptors
  • Areas of concern and excellence are open-ended
  • May removes a focus on the grade/points
  • May increase student creativity in project-based assignments

Disadvantage of analytic rubrics: Requires more work for instructors writing feedback

Step 3 (Optional): Look for templates and examples.

You might Google, “Rubric for persuasive essay at the college level” and see if there are any publicly available examples to start from. Ask your colleagues if they have used a rubric for a similar assignment. Some examples are also available at the end of this article. These rubrics can be a great starting point for you, but consider steps 3, 4, and 5 below to ensure that the rubric matches your assignment description, learning objectives and expectations.

Step 4: Define the assignment criteria

Make a list of the knowledge and skills are you measuring with the assignment/assessment Refer to your stated learning objectives, the assignment instructions, past examples of student work, etc. for help.

  Helpful strategies for defining grading criteria:

  • Collaborate with co-instructors, teaching assistants, and other colleagues
  • Brainstorm and discuss with students
  • Can they be observed and measured?
  • Are they important and essential?
  • Are they distinct from other criteria?
  • Are they phrased in precise, unambiguous language?
  • Revise the criteria as needed
  • Consider whether some are more important than others, and how you will weight them.

Step 5: Design the rating scale

Most ratings scales include between 3 and 5 levels. Consider the following questions when designing your rating scale:

  • Given what students are able to demonstrate in this assignment/assessment, what are the possible levels of achievement?
  • How many levels would you like to include (more levels means more detailed descriptions)
  • Will you use numbers and/or descriptive labels for each level of performance? (for example 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 and/or Exceeds expectations, Accomplished, Proficient, Developing, Beginning, etc.)
  • Don’t use too many columns, and recognize that some criteria can have more columns that others . The rubric needs to be comprehensible and organized. Pick the right amount of columns so that the criteria flow logically and naturally across levels.

Step 6: Write descriptions for each level of the rating scale

Artificial Intelligence tools like Chat GPT have proven to be useful tools for creating a rubric. You will want to engineer your prompt that you provide the AI assistant to ensure you get what you want. For example, you might provide the assignment description, the criteria you feel are important, and the number of levels of performance you want in your prompt. Use the results as a starting point, and adjust the descriptions as needed.

Building a rubric from scratch

For a single-point rubric , describe what would be considered “proficient,” i.e. B-level work, and provide that description. You might also include suggestions for students outside of the actual rubric about how they might surpass proficient-level work.

For analytic and holistic rubrics , c reate statements of expected performance at each level of the rubric.

  • Consider what descriptor is appropriate for each criteria, e.g., presence vs absence, complete vs incomplete, many vs none, major vs minor, consistent vs inconsistent, always vs never. If you have an indicator described in one level, it will need to be described in each level.
  • You might start with the top/exemplary level. What does it look like when a student has achieved excellence for each/every criterion? Then, look at the “bottom” level. What does it look like when a student has not achieved the learning goals in any way? Then, complete the in-between levels.
  • For an analytic rubric , do this for each particular criterion of the rubric so that every cell in the table is filled. These descriptions help students understand your expectations and their performance in regard to those expectations.

Well-written descriptions:

  • Describe observable and measurable behavior
  • Use parallel language across the scale
  • Indicate the degree to which the standards are met

Step 7: Create your rubric

Create your rubric in a table or spreadsheet in Word, Google Docs, Sheets, etc., and then transfer it by typing it into Moodle. You can also use online tools to create the rubric, but you will still have to type the criteria, indicators, levels, etc., into Moodle. Rubric creators: Rubistar , iRubric

Step 8: Pilot-test your rubric

Prior to implementing your rubric on a live course, obtain feedback from:

  • Teacher assistants

Try out your new rubric on a sample of student work. After you pilot-test your rubric, analyze the results to consider its effectiveness and revise accordingly.

  • Limit the rubric to a single page for reading and grading ease
  • Use parallel language . Use similar language and syntax/wording from column to column. Make sure that the rubric can be easily read from left to right or vice versa.
  • Use student-friendly language . Make sure the language is learning-level appropriate. If you use academic language or concepts, you will need to teach those concepts.
  • Share and discuss the rubric with your students . Students should understand that the rubric is there to help them learn, reflect, and self-assess. If students use a rubric, they will understand the expectations and their relevance to learning.
  • Consider scalability and reusability of rubrics. Create rubric templates that you can alter as needed for multiple assignments.
  • Maximize the descriptiveness of your language. Avoid words like “good” and “excellent.” For example, instead of saying, “uses excellent sources,” you might describe what makes a resource excellent so that students will know. You might also consider reducing the reliance on quantity, such as a number of allowable misspelled words. Focus instead, for example, on how distracting any spelling errors are.

Example of an analytic rubric for a final paper

Example of a holistic rubric for a final paper, single-point rubric, more examples:.

  • Single Point Rubric Template ( variation )
  • Analytic Rubric Template make a copy to edit
  • A Rubric for Rubrics
  • Bank of Online Discussion Rubrics in different formats
  • Mathematical Presentations Descriptive Rubric
  • Math Proof Assessment Rubric
  • Kansas State Sample Rubrics
  • Design Single Point Rubric

Technology Tools: Rubrics in Moodle

  • Moodle Docs: Rubrics
  • Moodle Docs: Grading Guide (use for single-point rubrics)

Tools with rubrics (other than Moodle)

  • Google Assignments
  • Turnitin Assignments: Rubric or Grading Form

Other resources

  • DePaul University (n.d.). Rubrics .
  • Gonzalez, J. (2014). Know your terms: Holistic, Analytic, and Single-Point Rubrics . Cult of Pedagogy.
  • Goodrich, H. (1996). Understanding rubrics . Teaching for Authentic Student Performance, 54 (4), 14-17. Retrieved from   
  • Miller, A. (2012). Tame the beast: tips for designing and using rubrics.
  • Ragupathi, K., Lee, A. (2020). Beyond Fairness and Consistency in Grading: The Role of Rubrics in Higher Education. In: Sanger, C., Gleason, N. (eds) Diversity and Inclusion in Global Higher Education. Palgrave Macmillan, Singapore.

Sample Essay Rubric for Elementary Teachers

  • Grading Students for Assessment
  • Lesson Plans
  • Becoming A Teacher
  • Assessments & Tests
  • Elementary Education
  • Special Education
  • Homeschooling
  • M.S., Education, Buffalo State College
  • B.S., Education, Buffalo State College

An essay rubric is a way teachers assess students' essay writing by using specific criteria to grade assignments. Essay rubrics save teachers time because all of the criteria are listed and organized into one convenient paper. If used effectively, rubrics can help improve students' writing .

How to Use an Essay Rubric

  • The best way to use an essay rubric is to give the rubric to the students before they begin their writing assignment. Review each criterion with the students and give them specific examples of what you want so they will know what is expected of them.
  • Next, assign students to write the essay, reminding them of the criteria and your expectations for the assignment.
  • Once students complete the essay have them first score their own essay using the rubric, and then switch with a partner. (This peer-editing process is a quick and reliable way to see how well the student did on their assignment. It's also good practice to learn criticism and become a more efficient writer.)
  • Once peer-editing is complete, have students hand in their essay's. Now it is your turn to evaluate the assignment according to the criteria on the rubric. Make sure to offer students examples if they did not meet the criteria listed.

Informal Essay Rubric

Formal essay rubric.

  • How to Create a Rubric in 6 Steps
  • Writing Rubrics
  • What Is a Rubric?
  • Holistic Grading (Composition)
  • How to Make a Rubric for Differentiation
  • A Simple Guide to Grading Elementary Students
  • How to Write a Philosophy of Education for Elementary Teachers
  • Tips to Cut Writing Assignment Grading Time
  • Assignment Biography: Student Criteria and Rubric for Writing
  • Rubrics - Quick Guide for all Content Areas
  • How to Teach the Compare and Contrast Essay
  • How to Calculate a Percentage and Letter Grade
  • Rubric Template Samples for Teachers
  • Group Project Grading Tip: Students Determine Fair Grade
  • Grading for Proficiency in the World of 4.0 GPAs
  • Stage a Debate in Class

Essay Rubric

Essay Rubric

About this printout

This rubric delineates specific expectations about an essay assignment to students and provides a means of assessing completed student essays.

Teaching with this printout

More ideas to try.

Grading rubrics can be of great benefit to both you and your students. For you, a rubric saves time and decreases subjectivity. Specific criteria are explicitly stated, facilitating the grading process and increasing your objectivity. For students, the use of grading rubrics helps them to meet or exceed expectations, to view the grading process as being “fair,” and to set goals for future learning. In order to help your students meet or exceed expectations of the assignment, be sure to discuss the rubric with your students when you assign an essay. It is helpful to show them examples of written pieces that meet and do not meet the expectations. As an added benefit, because the criteria are explicitly stated, the use of the rubric decreases the likelihood that students will argue about the grade they receive. The explicitness of the expectations helps students know exactly why they lost points on the assignment and aids them in setting goals for future improvement.

  • Routinely have students score peers’ essays using the rubric as the assessment tool. This increases their level of awareness of the traits that distinguish successful essays from those that fail to meet the criteria. Have peer editors use the Reviewer’s Comments section to add any praise, constructive criticism, or questions.
  • Alter some expectations or add additional traits on the rubric as needed. Students’ needs may necessitate making more rigorous criteria for advanced learners or less stringent guidelines for younger or special needs students. Furthermore, the content area for which the essay is written may require some alterations to the rubric. In social studies, for example, an essay about geographical landforms and their effect on the culture of a region might necessitate additional criteria about the use of specific terminology.
  • After you and your students have used the rubric, have them work in groups to make suggested alterations to the rubric to more precisely match their needs or the parameters of a particular writing assignment.
  • Print this resource

Explore Resources by Grade

  • Kindergarten K

USC shield

Center for Excellence in Teaching

Home > Resources > Academic essay rubric

Academic essay rubric

This is a grading rubric an instructor uses to assess students’ work on this type of assignment. It is a sample rubric that needs to be edited to reflect the specifics of a particular assignment. 

Download this file

Download this file [63.33 KB]

Back to Resources Page

Assessment Rubrics

A rubric is commonly defined as a tool that articulates the expectations for an assignment by listing criteria, and for each criteria, describing levels of quality (Andrade, 2000; Arter & Chappuis, 2007; Stiggins, 2001). Criteria are used in determining the level at which student work meets expectations. Markers of quality give students a clear idea about what must be done to demonstrate a certain level of mastery, understanding, or proficiency (i.e., "Exceeds Expectations" does xyz, "Meets Expectations" does only xy or yz, "Developing" does only x or y or z). Rubrics can be used for any assignment in a course, or for any way in which students are asked to demonstrate what they've learned. They can also be used to facilitate self and peer-reviews of student work.

Rubrics aren't just for summative evaluation. They can be used as a teaching tool as well. When used as part of a formative assessment, they can help students understand both the holistic nature and/or specific analytics of learning expected, the level of learning expected, and then make decisions about their current level of learning to inform revision and improvement (Reddy & Andrade, 2010). 

Why use rubrics?

Rubrics help instructors:

Provide students with feedback that is clear, directed and focused on ways to improve learning.

Demystify assignment expectations so students can focus on the work instead of guessing "what the instructor wants."

Reduce time spent on grading and develop consistency in how you evaluate student learning across students and throughout a class.

Rubrics help students:

Focus their efforts on completing assignments in line with clearly set expectations.

Self and Peer-reflect on their learning, making informed changes to achieve the desired learning level.

Developing a Rubric

During the process of developing a rubric, instructors might:

Select an assignment for your course - ideally one you identify as time intensive to grade, or students report as having unclear expectations.

Decide what you want students to demonstrate about their learning through that assignment. These are your criteria.

Identify the markers of quality on which you feel comfortable evaluating students’ level of learning - often along with a numerical scale (i.e., "Accomplished," "Emerging," "Beginning" for a developmental approach).

Give students the rubric ahead of time. Advise them to use it in guiding their completion of the assignment.

It can be overwhelming to create a rubric for every assignment in a class at once, so start by creating one rubric for one assignment. See how it goes and develop more from there! Also, do not reinvent the wheel. Rubric templates and examples exist all over the Internet, or consider asking colleagues if they have developed rubrics for similar assignments. 

Sample Rubrics

Examples of holistic and analytic rubrics : see Tables 2 & 3 in “Rubrics: Tools for Making Learning Goals and Evaluation Criteria Explicit for Both Teachers and Learners” (Allen & Tanner, 2006)

Examples across assessment types : see “Creating and Using Rubrics,” Carnegie Mellon Eberly Center for Teaching Excellence and & Educational Innovation

“VALUE Rubrics” : see the Association of American Colleges and Universities set of free, downloadable rubrics, with foci including creative thinking, problem solving, and information literacy. 

Andrade, H. 2000. Using rubrics to promote thinking and learning. Educational Leadership 57, no. 5: 13–18. Arter, J., and J. Chappuis. 2007. Creating and recognizing quality rubrics. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Merrill Prentice Hall. Stiggins, R.J. 2001. Student-involved classroom assessment. 3rd ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Reddy, Y., & Andrade, H. (2010). A review of rubric use in higher education. Assessment & Evaluation In Higher Education, 35(4), 435-448.

  • Faculty and Staff

twitter

Assessment and Curriculum Support Center

Creating and using rubrics.

Last Updated: 6 February 2024. Click here to view archived versions of this page.

On this page:

Part 1. What is a rubric? Part 2. Why use a rubric? Part 3. What are the parts of a rubric? Part 4. Developing a rubric Part 5. Sample rubrics Part 6. Scoring rubric group orientation and calibration Part 7. Suggestions for Using Rubrics in Courses Part 8. Equity-minded Considerations for Rubric Development Part 9. Tips for developing a rubric

Rubric examples:

  • Rubrics primarily for undergraduate outcomes and programs
  • Rubric repository for graduate degree programs

Workshop presentation slides and handouts:

  • Workshop handout (Word document)
  • How to Use a Rubric for Program Assessment (2010)
  • Techniques for Using Rubrics in Program Assessment by guest speaker Dannelle Stevens (2010)
  • Rubrics: Save Grading Time & Engage Students in Learning by guest speaker Dannelle Stevens (2009)

1. What is a rubric?

A rubric is an assessment tool often shaped like a matrix, which describes levels of achievement in a specific area of performance, understanding, or behavior.

There are two main types of rubrics:

Analytic Rubric : An analytic rubric specifies at least two characteristics to be assessed at each performance level and provides a separate score for each characteristic (e.g., a score on “formatting” and a score on “content development”).

  • Advantages: provides more detailed feedback on student performance; promotes consistent scoring across students and between raters
  • Disadvantages: more time consuming than applying a holistic rubric
  • You want to see strengths and weaknesses.
  • You want detailed feedback about student performance.

Holistic Rubric: A holistic rubrics provide a single score based on an overall impression of a student’s performance on a task.

  • Advantages: quick scoring; provides an overview of student achievement; efficient for large group scoring
  • Disadvantages: does not provided detailed information; not diagnostic; may be difficult for scorers to decide on one overall score
  • You want a quick snapshot of achievement.
  • A single dimension is adequate to define quality.

2. Why use a rubric?

  • A rubric creates a common framework and language for assessment.
  • Complex products or behaviors can be examined efficiently.
  • Well-trained reviewers apply the same criteria and standards.
  • Rubrics are criterion-referenced, rather than norm-referenced. Raters ask, “Did the student meet the criteria for level 5 of the rubric?” rather than “How well did this student do compared to other students?”
  • Using rubrics can lead to substantive conversations among faculty.
  • When faculty members collaborate to develop a rubric, it promotes shared expectations and grading practices.

Faculty members can use rubrics for program assessment. Examples:

The English Department collected essays from students in all sections of English 100. A random sample of essays was selected. A team of faculty members evaluated the essays by applying an analytic scoring rubric. Before applying the rubric, they “normed”–that is, they agreed on how to apply the rubric by scoring the same set of essays and discussing them until consensus was reached (see below: “6. Scoring rubric group orientation and calibration”). Biology laboratory instructors agreed to use a “Biology Lab Report Rubric” to grade students’ lab reports in all Biology lab sections, from 100- to 400-level. At the beginning of each semester, instructors met and discussed sample lab reports. They agreed on how to apply the rubric and their expectations for an “A,” “B,” “C,” etc., report in 100-level, 200-level, and 300- and 400-level lab sections. Every other year, a random sample of students’ lab reports are selected from 300- and 400-level sections. Each of those reports are then scored by a Biology professor. The score given by the course instructor is compared to the score given by the Biology professor. In addition, the scores are reported as part of the program’s assessment report. In this way, the program determines how well it is meeting its outcome, “Students will be able to write biology laboratory reports.”

3. What are the parts of a rubric?

Rubrics are composed of four basic parts. In its simplest form, the rubric includes:

  • A task description . The outcome being assessed or instructions students received for an assignment.
  • The characteristics to be rated (rows) . The skills, knowledge, and/or behavior to be demonstrated.
  • Beginning, approaching, meeting, exceeding
  • Emerging, developing, proficient, exemplary 
  • Novice, intermediate, intermediate high, advanced 
  • Beginning, striving, succeeding, soaring
  • A description of each characteristic at each level of mastery/scale (cells) .

4. Developing a rubric

Step 1: Identify what you want to assess

Step 2: Identify the characteristics to be rated (rows). These are also called “dimensions.”

  • Specify the skills, knowledge, and/or behaviors that you will be looking for.
  • Limit the characteristics to those that are most important to the assessment.

Step 3: Identify the levels of mastery/scale (columns).

Tip: Aim for an even number (4 or 6) because when an odd number is used, the middle tends to become the “catch-all” category.

Step 4: Describe each level of mastery for each characteristic/dimension (cells).

  • Describe the best work you could expect using these characteristics. This describes the top category.
  • Describe an unacceptable product. This describes the lowest category.
  • Develop descriptions of intermediate-level products for intermediate categories.
Important: Each description and each characteristic should be mutually exclusive.

Step 5: Test rubric.

  • Apply the rubric to an assignment.
  • Share with colleagues.
Tip: Faculty members often find it useful to establish the minimum score needed for the student work to be deemed passable. For example, faculty members may decided that a “1” or “2” on a 4-point scale (4=exemplary, 3=proficient, 2=marginal, 1=unacceptable), does not meet the minimum quality expectations. We encourage a standard setting session to set the score needed to meet expectations (also called a “cutscore”). Monica has posted materials from standard setting workshops, one offered on campus and the other at a national conference (includes speaker notes with the presentation slides). They may set their criteria for success as 90% of the students must score 3 or higher. If assessment study results fall short, action will need to be taken.

Step 6: Discuss with colleagues. Review feedback and revise.

Important: When developing a rubric for program assessment, enlist the help of colleagues. Rubrics promote shared expectations and consistent grading practices which benefit faculty members and students in the program.

5. Sample rubrics

Rubrics are on our Rubric Bank page and in our Rubric Repository (Graduate Degree Programs) . More are available at the Assessment and Curriculum Support Center in Crawford Hall (hard copy).

These open as Word documents and are examples from outside UH.

  • Group Participation (analytic rubric)
  • Participation (holistic rubric)
  • Design Project (analytic rubric)
  • Critical Thinking (analytic rubric)
  • Media and Design Elements (analytic rubric; portfolio)
  • Writing (holistic rubric; portfolio)

6. Scoring rubric group orientation and calibration

When using a rubric for program assessment purposes, faculty members apply the rubric to pieces of student work (e.g., reports, oral presentations, design projects). To produce dependable scores, each faculty member needs to interpret the rubric in the same way. The process of training faculty members to apply the rubric is called “norming.” It’s a way to calibrate the faculty members so that scores are accurate and consistent across the faculty. Below are directions for an assessment coordinator carrying out this process.

Suggested materials for a scoring session:

  • Copies of the rubric
  • Copies of the “anchors”: pieces of student work that illustrate each level of mastery. Suggestion: have 6 anchor pieces (2 low, 2 middle, 2 high)
  • Score sheets
  • Extra pens, tape, post-its, paper clips, stapler, rubber bands, etc.

Hold the scoring session in a room that:

  • Allows the scorers to spread out as they rate the student pieces
  • Has a chalk or white board, smart board, or flip chart
  • Describe the purpose of the activity, stressing how it fits into program assessment plans. Explain that the purpose is to assess the program, not individual students or faculty, and describe ethical guidelines, including respect for confidentiality and privacy.
  • Describe the nature of the products that will be reviewed, briefly summarizing how they were obtained.
  • Describe the scoring rubric and its categories. Explain how it was developed.
  • Analytic: Explain that readers should rate each dimension of an analytic rubric separately, and they should apply the criteria without concern for how often each score (level of mastery) is used. Holistic: Explain that readers should assign the score or level of mastery that best describes the whole piece; some aspects of the piece may not appear in that score and that is okay. They should apply the criteria without concern for how often each score is used.
  • Give each scorer a copy of several student products that are exemplars of different levels of performance. Ask each scorer to independently apply the rubric to each of these products, writing their ratings on a scrap sheet of paper.
  • Once everyone is done, collect everyone’s ratings and display them so everyone can see the degree of agreement. This is often done on a blackboard, with each person in turn announcing his/her ratings as they are entered on the board. Alternatively, the facilitator could ask raters to raise their hands when their rating category is announced, making the extent of agreement very clear to everyone and making it very easy to identify raters who routinely give unusually high or low ratings.
  • Guide the group in a discussion of their ratings. There will be differences. This discussion is important to establish standards. Attempt to reach consensus on the most appropriate rating for each of the products being examined by inviting people who gave different ratings to explain their judgments. Raters should be encouraged to explain by making explicit references to the rubric. Usually consensus is possible, but sometimes a split decision is developed, e.g., the group may agree that a product is a “3-4” split because it has elements of both categories. This is usually not a problem. You might allow the group to revise the rubric to clarify its use but avoid allowing the group to drift away from the rubric and learning outcome(s) being assessed.
  • Once the group is comfortable with how the rubric is applied, the rating begins. Explain how to record ratings using the score sheet and explain the procedures. Reviewers begin scoring.
  • Are results sufficiently reliable?
  • What do the results mean? Are we satisfied with the extent of students’ learning?
  • Who needs to know the results?
  • What are the implications of the results for curriculum, pedagogy, or student support services?
  • How might the assessment process, itself, be improved?

7. Suggestions for Using Rubrics in Courses

  • Use the rubric to grade student work. Hand out the rubric with the assignment so students will know your expectations and how they’ll be graded. This should help students master your learning outcomes by guiding their work in appropriate directions.
  • Use a rubric for grading student work and return the rubric with the grading on it. Faculty save time writing extensive comments; they just circle or highlight relevant segments of the rubric. Some faculty members include room for additional comments on the rubric page, either within each section or at the end.
  • Develop a rubric with your students for an assignment or group project. Students can the monitor themselves and their peers using agreed-upon criteria that they helped develop. Many faculty members find that students will create higher standards for themselves than faculty members would impose on them.
  • Have students apply your rubric to sample products before they create their own. Faculty members report that students are quite accurate when doing this, and this process should help them evaluate their own projects as they are being developed. The ability to evaluate, edit, and improve draft documents is an important skill.
  • Have students exchange paper drafts and give peer feedback using the rubric. Then, give students a few days to revise before submitting the final draft to you. You might also require that they turn in the draft and peer-scored rubric with their final paper.
  • Have students self-assess their products using the rubric and hand in their self-assessment with the product; then, faculty members and students can compare self- and faculty-generated evaluations.

8. Equity-minded considerations for rubric development

Ensure Rubric Criteria is Transparent & Explicit

Transparency is a core tenet of equity-minded assessment practice. Students should know and understand how they are being evaluated as early as possible.

  • Make the rubric publicly available & easily accessible. We recommend publishing on your program or department website.
  • Have course instructors introduce and use the program rubric in their own courses. Instructors can then explain to students connections between the rubric criteria and the course and program SLOs.
  • Write criteria using language that is meaningful and understandable to students.
  • For example, instructors can provide annotated examples of student work using the rubric language as a resource for students.

Meaningfully Involve Students and Other Stakeholders

Rubrics created by faculty alone risk perpetuating unseen biases. The evaluation criteria used will inherently reflect faculty perspectives, values, and assumptions. Including students and other stakeholders in developing criteria helps to ensure performance expectations are aligned between faculty and students. Consider the following strategies to meaningfully involve students and other stakeholders:

  • Have students read each evaluation criteria and talk out loud about what they think it means. This will allow you to identify what language is clear and where there is still confusion.
  • Ask students to use their language to interpret the rubric and provide a student version of the rubric.
  • If you use this strategy, it is essential to create an inclusive environment where students and faculty have equal opportunity to provide input.
  • Be sure to incorporate feedback from faculty and instructors who teach diverse courses, levels, and in different sub-disciplinary topics. Faculty and instructors who teach introductory courses have valuable experiences and perspectives that may differ from those who teach higher-level courses. Faculty – make clear different faculty levels experiences and sub-disciplines
  • Ask alumni, potential employers, and community members for feedback on evaluation criteria and rubric language. This will ensure evaluation criteria reflect what is important for all stakeholders.

Honor Students’ Strengths in Performance Descriptions

When describing students’ performance at different levels on your rubric, use language that describes what students can do rather than what they cannot do. For example:

  • Instead of: Students cannot make coherent arguments.
  • Use: Students can make coherent arguments occasionally.

9. Tips for developing a rubric

  • Find and adapt an existing rubric! It is rare to find a rubric that is exactly right for your situation, but you can adapt an already existing rubric that has worked well for others and save a great deal of time. A faculty member in your program may already have a good one.
  • Evaluate the rubric . Ask yourself: A) Does the rubric relate to the outcome(s) being assessed? (If yes, success!) B) Does it address anything extraneous? (If yes, delete.) C) Is the rubric useful, feasible, manageable, and practical? (If yes, find multiple ways to use the rubric: program assessment, assignment grading, peer review, student self assessment.)
  • Collect samples of student work that exemplify each point on the scale or level. A rubric will not be meaningful to students or colleagues until the anchors/benchmarks/exemplars are available.
  • Expect to revise.
  • When you have a good rubric, SHARE IT!

Sources consulted:

  • Rubric Library , Institutional Research, Assessment & Planning, California State University-Fresno
  • The Basics of Rubrics [PDF], Schreyer Institute, Penn State
  • Creating Rubrics , Teaching Methods and Management, TeacherVision
  • Allen, Mary – University of Hawai’i at Manoa Spring 2008 Assessment Workshops, May 13-14, 2008 [available at the Assessment and Curriculum Support Center]
  • Mertler, Craig A. (2001). Designing scoring rubrics for your classroom. Practical Assessment, Research & Evaluation , 7(25).
  • NPEC Sourcebook on Assessment: Definitions and Assessment Methods for Communication, Leadership, Information Literacy, Quantitative Reasoning, and Quantitative Skills . [PDF] (June 2005)

Last Updated: 6 February 2024.

  • Grades 6-12
  • School Leaders

Black History Month for Kids: Google Slides, Resources, and More!

15 Helpful Scoring Rubric Examples for All Grades and Subjects

In the end, they actually make grading easier.

Collage of scoring rubric examples including written response rubric and interactive notebook rubric

When it comes to student assessment and evaluation, there are a lot of methods to consider. In some cases, testing is the best way to assess a student’s knowledge, and the answers are either right or wrong. But often, assessing a student’s performance is much less clear-cut. In these situations, a scoring rubric is often the way to go, especially if you’re using standards-based grading . Here’s what you need to know about this useful tool, along with lots of rubric examples to get you started.

What is a scoring rubric?

In the United States, a rubric is a guide that lays out the performance expectations for an assignment. It helps students understand what’s required of them, and guides teachers through the evaluation process. (Note that in other countries, the term “rubric” may instead refer to the set of instructions at the beginning of an exam. To avoid confusion, some people use the term “scoring rubric” instead.)

A rubric generally has three parts:

  • Performance criteria: These are the various aspects on which the assignment will be evaluated. They should align with the desired learning outcomes for the assignment.
  • Rating scale: This could be a number system (often 1 to 4) or words like “exceeds expectations, meets expectations, below expectations,” etc.
  • Indicators: These describe the qualities needed to earn a specific rating for each of the performance criteria. The level of detail may vary depending on the assignment and the purpose of the rubric itself.

Rubrics take more time to develop up front, but they help ensure more consistent assessment, especially when the skills being assessed are more subjective. A well-developed rubric can actually save teachers a lot of time when it comes to grading. What’s more, sharing your scoring rubric with students in advance often helps improve performance . This way, students have a clear picture of what’s expected of them and what they need to do to achieve a specific grade or performance rating.

Learn more about why and how to use a rubric here.

Types of Rubric

There are three basic rubric categories, each with its own purpose.

Holistic Rubric

A holistic scoring rubric laying out the criteria for a rating of 1 to 4 when creating an infographic

Source: Cambrian College

This type of rubric combines all the scoring criteria in a single scale. They’re quick to create and use, but they have drawbacks. If a student’s work spans different levels, it can be difficult to decide which score to assign. They also make it harder to provide feedback on specific aspects.

Traditional letter grades are a type of holistic rubric. So are the popular “hamburger rubric” and “ cupcake rubric ” examples. Learn more about holistic rubrics here.

Analytic Rubric

Layout of an analytic scoring rubric, describing the different sections like criteria, rating, and indicators

Source: University of Nebraska

Analytic rubrics are much more complex and generally take a great deal more time up front to design. They include specific details of the expected learning outcomes, and descriptions of what criteria are required to meet various performance ratings in each. Each rating is assigned a point value, and the total number of points earned determines the overall grade for the assignment.

Though they’re more time-intensive to create, analytic rubrics actually save time while grading. Teachers can simply circle or highlight any relevant phrases in each rating, and add a comment or two if needed. They also help ensure consistency in grading, and make it much easier for students to understand what’s expected of them.

Learn more about analytic rubrics here.

Developmental Rubric

A developmental rubric for kindergarten skills, with illustrations to describe the indicators of criteria

Source: Deb’s Data Digest

A developmental rubric is a type of analytic rubric, but it’s used to assess progress along the way rather than determining a final score on an assignment. The details in these rubrics help students understand their achievements, as well as highlight the specific skills they still need to improve.

Developmental rubrics are essentially a subset of analytic rubrics. They leave off the point values, though, and focus instead on giving feedback using the criteria and indicators of performance.

Learn how to use developmental rubrics here.

Ready to create your own rubrics? Find general tips on designing rubrics here. Then, check out these examples across all grades and subjects to inspire you.

Elementary School Rubric Examples

These elementary school rubric examples come from real teachers who use them with their students. Adapt them to fit your needs and grade level.

Reading Fluency Rubric

A developmental rubric example for reading fluency

You can use this one as an analytic rubric by counting up points to earn a final score, or just to provide developmental feedback. There’s a second rubric page available specifically to assess prosody (reading with expression).

Learn more: Teacher Thrive

Reading Comprehension Rubric

Reading comprehension rubric, with criteria and indicators for different comprehension skills

The nice thing about this rubric is that you can use it at any grade level, for any text. If you like this style, you can get a reading fluency rubric here too.

Learn more: Pawprints Resource Center

Written Response Rubric

Two anchor charts, one showing

Rubrics aren’t just for huge projects. They can also help kids work on very specific skills, like this one for improving written responses on assessments.

Learn more: Dianna Radcliffe: Teaching Upper Elementary and More

Interactive Notebook Rubric

Interactive Notebook rubric example, with criteria and indicators for assessment

If you use interactive notebooks as a learning tool , this rubric can help kids stay on track and meet your expectations.

Learn more: Classroom Nook

Project Rubric

Rubric that can be used for assessing any elementary school project

Use this simple rubric as it is, or tweak it to include more specific indicators for the project you have in mind.

Learn more: Tales of a Title One Teacher

Behavior Rubric

Rubric for assessing student behavior in school and classroom

Developmental rubrics are perfect for assessing behavior and helping students identify opportunities for improvement. Send these home regularly to keep parents in the loop.

Learn more: Teachers.net Gazette

Middle School Rubric Examples

In middle school, use rubrics to offer detailed feedback on projects, presentations, and more. Be sure to share them with students in advance, and encourage them to use them as they work so they’ll know if they’re meeting expectations.

Argumentative Writing Rubric

An argumentative rubric example to use with middle school students

Argumentative writing is a part of language arts, social studies, science, and more. That makes this rubric especially useful.

Learn more: Dr. Caitlyn Tucker

Role-Play Rubric

A rubric example for assessing student role play in the classroom

Role-plays can be really useful when teaching social and critical thinking skills, but it’s hard to assess them. Try a rubric like this one to evaluate and provide useful feedback.

Learn more: A Question of Influence

Art Project Rubric

A rubric used to grade middle school art projects

Art is one of those subjects where grading can feel very subjective. Bring some objectivity to the process with a rubric like this.

Source: Art Ed Guru

Diorama Project Rubric

A rubric for grading middle school diorama projects

You can use diorama projects in almost any subject, and they’re a great chance to encourage creativity. Simplify the grading process and help kids know how to make their projects shine with this scoring rubric.

Learn more: Historyourstory.com

Oral Presentation Rubric

Rubric example for grading oral presentations given by middle school students

Rubrics are terrific for grading presentations, since you can include a variety of skills and other criteria. Consider letting students use a rubric like this to offer peer feedback too.

Learn more: Bright Hub Education

High School Rubric Examples

In high school, it’s important to include your grading rubrics when you give assignments like presentations, research projects, or essays. Kids who go on to college will definitely encounter rubrics, so helping them become familiar with them now will help in the future.

Presentation Rubric

Example of a rubric used to grade a high school project presentation

Analyze a student’s presentation both for content and communication skills with a rubric like this one. If needed, create a separate one for content knowledge with even more criteria and indicators.

Learn more: Michael A. Pena Jr.

Debate Rubric

A rubric for assessing a student's performance in a high school debate

Debate is a valuable learning tool that encourages critical thinking and oral communication skills. This rubric can help you assess those skills objectively.

Learn more: Education World

Project-Based Learning Rubric

A rubric for assessing high school project based learning assignments

Implementing project-based learning can be time-intensive, but the payoffs are worth it. Try this rubric to make student expectations clear and end-of-project assessment easier.

Learn more: Free Technology for Teachers

100-Point Essay Rubric

Rubric for scoring an essay with a final score out of 100 points

Need an easy way to convert a scoring rubric to a letter grade? This example for essay writing earns students a final score out of 100 points.

Learn more: Learn for Your Life

Drama Performance Rubric

A rubric teachers can use to evaluate a student's participation and performance in a theater production

If you’re unsure how to grade a student’s participation and performance in drama class, consider this example. It offers lots of objective criteria and indicators to evaluate.

Learn more: Chase March

How do you use rubrics in your classroom? Come share your thoughts and exchange ideas in the WeAreTeachers HELPLINE group on Facebook .

Plus, 25 of the best alternative assessment ideas ..

Scoring rubrics help establish expectations and ensure assessment consistency. Use these rubric examples to help you design your own.

You Might Also Like

Author visit with Shannon Olsen

Classroom Author Visit With Shannon Olsen—Sign Your Class Up To Attend!

Bring the author of "Our Class Is a Family" into your classroom! Continue Reading

Copyright © 2023. All rights reserved. 5335 Gate Parkway, Jacksonville, FL 32256

Search the blog

Input your search keywords and press Enter.

Vibrant Teaching

Vibrant Teaching

Teaching Resources Creator and Blogger

3 Types of Writing Rubrics for Effective Assessments

writing-rubrics

There are so many different writing rubrics out there and it may be difficult to find the right one. Below you will find a guide with 3 types of effective writing rubrics. Choosing the right one depends on the writing genre and your needs for the assessment.

Student-Friendly Rubrics

There are two ways to think about student-friendly rubrics. The first way is to use a rubric that students can complete as a self-assessment. The second way is to use a rubric that is completed by the teacher but is easy for students to understand. These rubrics are often based on the standards but shown in a different way. Instead of writing the actual standard on the rubric, include a one or two-word category.

See the example below of a third grade informative writing rubric. The first rubric uses the words introduction, content, linking words, closing, and mechanics for the categories. The second rubric lists each standard that goes with those categories. As you can see, the first option covers the same information but uses fewer words and is much easier for students to use and understand.

writing-rubrics-3rd-grade

When do you use student-friendly rubrics? These are great for students to assess themselves. The student and teacher can fill out the rubric separately and then meet for a conference to discuss any differences. This same strategy can also be done with two students, but instead of a conference, they will meet to edit and revise their work. Another option is for teachers to fill out the writing rubric and hand it back to students with feedback. The student-friendly rubrics are easy for kids to understand and are still aligned with the standards.

what-are-prompts-in-writing

Teacher-Friendly Rubrics

Teacher-friendly rubrics list each standard and use more details in the descriptions. This helps teachers know what to look for when assessing a writing piece. It will be very clear from the rubric whether or not the student is meeting or exceeding the standard. These writing rubrics are also quick and easy for teachers to use but may be more difficult for students to understand.

The examples below are standards based teacher-friendly rubrics. On the left side, you will see each Common Core Standard. The descriptions on the right side match each standard accordingly. These rubrics are used for assessing narrative writing in 1st grade, 2nd grade, 3rd grade, 4th grade, and 5th grade.

first-grade-rubric-for-writing

When do you use teacher-friendly rubrics? These are ideal when a teacher needs to get an accurate assessment for recording grades or writing report cards. They can choose whether or not to hand these rubrics back to students or use them for their records. Teacher-friendly rubrics are also helpful to show parents, especially at conferences.

Time-Saving Rubrics

Time-saving rubrics are a combination of student-friendly and teacher-friendly rubrics. These are standards based and list each standard on the left side. The difference is that instead of a description there is a number in each box such as 1, 2, 3, or 4. These numbers tell whether or not the student is meeting the standard.

1= needs support

2 = approaching standard, 3 = meets standard, 4 = exceeds standard.

The benefits of these rubrics are that they save time and energy by easily circling the number for each standard. It is quick for teachers to use but also easy for students to understand. Some teachers may also choose to include a section for the total score and comments depending on their needs. Check out some of the examples below for opinion writing.

first-grade-rubric-for-writing

When do you use time-saving rubrics? Well of course these are helpful when teachers want to save time. The best part is the rubrics are still standards based but also very easy for students and parents to understand. Use these anytime!

Writing Rubrics Conclusion

I hope you have found these 3 types of writing rubrics helpful and will utilize them with your class. Think about what your goal is with the assessment and choose the best rubric for both you and your students. You may find that a mix of all three is beneficial throughout the school year.

Writing Rubrics by Grade Level

Grab these standards based writing rubrics. Each grade level includes 9 rubrics in 3 different options . Choose from student-friendly, teacher-friendly, and time-saving rubrics. These are ideal for assessing narrative, opinion, and informative pieces. Click each grade level below to learn more. Also, check out this Monthly Writing Prompts blog post for more resources and ideas.

first-grade-rubric-for-writing

Middle School Writing Rubrics

writing-rubrics-6th-grade

Angela Sutton

Related posts.

assessment rubric for essay writing

How to Find Perimeter in 3 Easy Ways

Informational Writing: Teaching All About Books

Informational Writing: Teaching All About Books

assessment rubric for essay writing

20 Prompts for Information Writing That Empower Students

No comments, leave a reply cancel reply.

I accept the Privacy Policy

assessment rubric for essay writing

I specialize in helping elementary teachers with writing resources, tips, and ideas. My goal is to save teachers time and energy so they can be vibrant inside and outside of the classroom! Read More

SEARCH THE BLOG

Subscribe to our mailing list.

Get the news right in your inbox!

Health and Wellness

unique college essay

Rubrics for Essay Writing Assessment: A Comprehensive Guide

Introduction.

Rubrics are systematic scoring guides used to evaluate and assess students’ essays based on predefined criteria and performance levels. They provide a clear and structured framework for grading essays, ensuring that educators assess students’ work consistently and objectively.

Using rubrics in essay writing assessment is crucial for several reasons. Firstly, they help establish clear expectations and grading criteria, enabling both students and teachers to understand what is required for each level of performance. This transparency promotes fairness in evaluation, as students know exactly what they need to do to achieve a certain grade.

Secondly, rubrics provide a structured and organized approach to essay evaluation. Instead of relying solely on subjective judgments, rubrics focus on specific aspects of the essay, such as content, organization, language, and mechanics. This structured evaluation helps ensure that all essays are assessed consistently and impartially, regardless of who is doing the grading.

In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the essential components of effective rubrics, including how to design them for different types of essays and grade levels. Additionally, we will explore the advantages of using rubrics in essay writing assessment, such as promoting clarity in feedback, streamlining the grading process, and empowering students to take ownership of their learning. By the end of this exploration, educators will gain valuable insights into how to implement rubrics effectively in their classrooms to enhance the essay assessment process and foster student growth and achievement.

Understanding Rubrics

Rubrics are scoring tools that provide a clear and systematic way to evaluate students’ work, including essays. They consist of a set of criteria and performance levels that define different levels of proficiency. Rubrics serve as guidelines for educators to assess students’ work and provide constructive feedback on their performance.

B. Different Types of Rubrics: Holistic and Analytic: There are two main types of rubrics used in educational settings: holistic and analytic.

  • Holistic Rubrics: Holistic rubrics provide a broad overview of the overall quality of the essay. They assess the essay as a whole, considering the overall impression and effectiveness of the writing. Holistic rubrics are particularly useful for quick and summative assessments, as they provide a general sense of the essay’s quality without breaking down specific components.
  • Analytic Rubrics: Analytic rubrics, on the other hand, break down the essay into specific components or criteria, such as content, organization, language, and mechanics. Each criterion is evaluated separately, allowing for a more detailed assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of the essay. Analytic rubrics provide more targeted feedback and help students understand their performance in different areas.

C. How Rubrics Enhance Clarity and Objectivity in Grading: Rubrics play a crucial role in enhancing clarity and objectivity in the grading process. By defining specific criteria and performance levels, rubrics establish clear expectations for what constitutes excellent, satisfactory, and unsatisfactory work. This clarity ensures that both educators and students have a shared understanding of the assessment criteria.

Moreover, rubrics provide a structured and standardized approach to grading, reducing the risk of subjective bias in evaluation. With rubrics, grading becomes more objective and consistent, regardless of who is assessing the essays. As a result, students receive fair and equitable feedback, and educators can focus on providing constructive comments that help students improve their writing skills. By using rubrics, educators can ensure that the essay writing assessment process is transparent, consistent, and meaningful for student learning and growth.

Components of an Effective Rubric

An effective rubric for essay writing assessment includes a clear identification of key criteria that reflect the essential elements of a well-written essay. These criteria typically encompass various aspects of the essay, such as content, organization, language, mechanics, and argumentation. Each criterion should be specific and measurable, allowing for a comprehensive evaluation of the essay’s quality.

B. Defining Levels of Performance for Each Criterion: For each identified criterion, the rubric should establish distinct levels of performance that represent varying degrees of proficiency. Commonly used performance levels are “excellent,” “proficient,” “satisfactory,” and “needs improvement.” These levels provide a clear delineation of the expected standard for each criterion, making it easier for both educators and students to gauge the essay’s strengths and weaknesses.

C. Weighting Criteria to Reflect Their Importance in the Overall Assessment: Not all criteria carry the same weight in an essay’s overall assessment. Some aspects may be more critical to the essay’s success than others. Therefore, an effective rubric should incorporate a weighting system that reflects the relative importance of each criterion. This weighting can be done through point allocation or percentage distribution. By weighting criteria, the rubric ensures that certain areas, such as content and organization, have a more significant impact on the final evaluation.

For example, in an essay rubric, content and argumentation might be weighted higher than language and mechanics, as the strength of the essay’s arguments and supporting evidence is crucial to its overall quality. On the other hand, language and mechanics are still essential components, but they might have a lower impact on the final grade.

The combination of these components in an effective rubric allows educators to provide detailed and constructive feedback to students while promoting a consistent and objective evaluation process. It also helps students understand the specific areas they need to focus on for improvement, ultimately supporting their growth as proficient essay writers.

Creating Rubrics for Different Essay Types

Different types of essays require distinct approaches and skill sets. When creating rubrics for different essay types, educators should consider the specific characteristics and goals of each type. For argumentative essays, the rubric may emphasize the strength of the thesis statement, the quality of evidence and supporting arguments, and the effectiveness of counterarguments. In contrast, rubrics for expository essays may focus on the clarity of explanations, use of evidence, and adherence to the chosen organizational structure. For narrative essays, the rubric might assess the coherence of the story, the development of characters, and the use of descriptive language to evoke emotions.

B. Customizing Rubrics for Specific Grade Levels and Learning Objectives: Rubrics should be tailored to the grade level and learning objectives of the students. The complexity and expectations for essay writing evolve as students progress through different grade levels. As a result, rubrics should be adjusted to align with the appropriate grade level’s developmental milestones and learning goals. For instance, elementary school rubrics may prioritize foundational writing skills, while high school rubrics may demand more sophisticated analysis and critical thinking.

C. Incorporating Specific Requirements and Guidelines into Rubrics: Each essay assignment may come with specific requirements and guidelines from the educator. Rubrics should reflect these requirements and provide students with a clear understanding of what is expected of them. This may include adhering to specific formatting styles, word limits, citation conventions, or content-related criteria. Additionally, the rubric can include elements related to creativity, originality, and adherence to the assignment prompt.

By creating essay-specific rubrics that are customized to the students’ grade level and aligned with learning objectives, educators can effectively assess students’ writing proficiency and provide targeted feedback. This approach empowers students to understand their strengths and areas for improvement, encourages growth in writing skills, and ensures a fair and consistent evaluation process across different essay types and grade levels.

Advantages of Rubrics in Essay Writing Assessment

Rubrics promote consistency in grading by providing a clear and standardized set of criteria for assessment. With well-defined levels of performance, educators can evaluate each essay objectively and fairly, ensuring that all students are assessed using the same established standards. This consistency helps eliminate subjective biases, ensuring that every student’s work is evaluated based on their actual performance rather than personal preferences.

Providing Clear Feedback to Students for Improvement

Rubrics serve as valuable tools for constructive feedback. By detailing the specific strengths and weaknesses of an essay based on predefined criteria, rubrics offer students comprehensive feedback on their writing. This targeted feedback allows students to understand areas where they excel and areas that require improvement. Armed with this information, students can work on enhancing specific writing skills and refine their essays with a clear focus on growth.

Streamlining the Assessment Process for Educators

Rubrics simplify the assessment process for educators by providing a structured framework for grading. Instead of evaluating essays based on a vague sense of quality, rubrics enable educators to methodically review each aspect of the essay and assign corresponding scores. This streamlining saves time and effort for teachers, making the evaluation process more efficient and consistent.

By leveraging the advantages of rubrics, educators can create a supportive and effective environment for students to develop their essay writing skills. Consistent and fair grading, combined with clear feedback, motivates students to improve and empowers them to take ownership of their writing abilities. Meanwhile, teachers can effectively manage their assessment workload and provide valuable guidance for student growth, making rubrics an indispensable tool for essay writing assessment.

Implementing Rubrics in the Classroom

To introduce rubrics effectively, educators can start by explaining the purpose and benefits of using rubrics for essay writing assessment. They can conduct interactive discussions to familiarize students with the different components and criteria of a rubric. Providing examples of well-graded essays using rubrics can help students understand how to meet the desired standards. Engaging students in the process of creating a rubric or co-constructing one can also enhance their understanding of the assessment criteria and promote a sense of ownership in the evaluation process.

The Role of Rubrics in Promoting Self-Assessment and Peer Assessment

Rubrics play a crucial role in encouraging self-assessment among students. After completing an essay, students can use the rubric as a checklist to assess their work against the defined criteria. This self-assessment enables them to identify areas of strength and areas that need improvement, fostering a sense of responsibility for their own learning. Rubrics also facilitate peer assessment , where students review each other’s essays using the same rubric. Peer assessment not only provides additional feedback but also cultivates a collaborative learning environment.

Overcoming Challenges in Using Rubrics Effectively

While rubrics offer significant benefits, some challenges may arise in their implementation. One challenge is ensuring that the rubric aligns with the learning objectives and accurately reflects the expectations for the essay. Rubrics may need periodic review and refinement to remain relevant. Another challenge is avoiding an overemphasis on grades, which might lead students to focus solely on meeting the rubric’s criteria rather than expressing creativity and critical thinking in their essays. Educators should communicate that rubrics serve as tools for improvement rather than just assigning scores.

By thoughtfully introducing rubrics, encouraging self-assessment, and promoting peer assessment, educators can create an environment where students actively engage in the evaluation process. This involvement fosters a deeper understanding of the assessment criteria and encourages students to take ownership of their learning and writing progress. While challenges may arise, educators can address them by regularly reviewing and refining rubrics to maintain their effectiveness as valuable tools for essay writing assessment in the classroom.

Assessing the Effectiveness of Rubrics

To assess the effectiveness of rubrics, educators can compare student performance before and after the implementation of rubrics. They can analyze data on student grades and achievement to determine if the use of rubrics has resulted in improved performance and learning outcomes. Additionally, educators can conduct formative assessments , such as quizzes or writing samples, to gauge students’ understanding of the assessment criteria and their ability to meet the defined standards.

Feedback from Teachers and Students on the Use of Rubrics

Gathering feedback from both teachers and students is crucial to understanding the strengths and weaknesses of the rubric implementation. Teachers can reflect on their experiences with using rubrics and provide insights into the effectiveness of the assessment tool. They can also offer suggestions for improvements or modifications to better align the rubrics with the learning objectives. Similarly, students’ perspectives are valuable in assessing the impact of rubrics on their learning experiences. Surveys or interviews can be conducted to gather feedback on whether the rubrics were clear and helpful in guiding their writing process.

Making Improvements and Adjustments Based on Assessment Results

After analyzing the data and feedback, educators can make informed decisions about the effectiveness of the rubrics. If the assessment results and feedback indicate positive outcomes, educators can consider replicating successful rubric practices across different essays and grade levels. On the other hand, if areas for improvement are identified, educators can make adjustments to the rubrics to address any shortcomings or challenges. This might involve refining the wording of criteria, revising the weightage of different components, or providing additional examples to clarify expectations.

By conducting thorough assessments and gathering feedback from teachers and students, educators can continuously improve the effectiveness of rubrics in essay writing assessment. This ongoing evaluation process allows for data-driven decision-making and ensures that the rubrics remain a valuable tool for promoting transparency, consistency, and fairness in grading. As educators make improvements and adjustments, they enhance the overall learning experience, empowering students to excel in their writing and achieve their academic goals.

Best Practices for Using Essay Writing Assessment

To ensure the essay writing assessment is effective, educators should align the assessment criteria and rubrics with the specific learning objectives and curriculum standards. By doing so, the assessment becomes a meaningful tool for measuring students’ progress toward the intended learning outcomes. Educators can identify the key skills, knowledge, and competencies they want students to demonstrate in their essays and design rubrics that reflect these objectives. Aligning the assessment with learning objectives also helps students understand the purpose and relevance of the writing task, making the assessment more meaningful to their learning journey.

Regularly Updating and Refining Rubrics Based on Student Needs and Feedback

Educators should view rubrics as dynamic tools that can evolve based on student needs and feedback. Regularly updating and refining rubrics allow educators to respond to the changing learning needs of their students and improve the effectiveness of the assessment process. Educators can gather feedback from students on the clarity and helpfulness of the rubrics, as well as seek input from colleagues to identify areas for improvement. By making adjustments to the rubrics, educators can create assessment tools that are more aligned with students’ learning experiences and promote continuous growth and development.

Sharing Rubrics with Students in Advance to Set Clear Expectations

Transparency is essential in the essay writing assessment process. Educators should share the rubrics with students well in advance of the writing task to set clear expectations and provide guidance on what is required for successful completion. When students understand the assessment criteria and how their work will be evaluated, they can better focus their efforts and make purposeful decisions in their writing process. Sharing rubrics also empowers students to self-assess their work and make revisions to meet the defined standards. It fosters a sense of ownership and responsibility in students’ learning and promotes a growth mindset.

By adhering to these best practices, educators can maximize the benefits of essay writing assessment and rubrics. They can create a supportive learning environment that empowers students to take ownership of their writing, make meaningful progress, and develop essential skills for academic and professional success. As educators continuously improve their assessment practices, they contribute to a positive and impactful learning experience for their students, fostering a culture of growth, reflection, and continuous improvement in writing proficiency.

Rubrics and Assessment in Remote Learning Environments

When transitioning to remote learning environments, educators need to adapt their essay writing assessment rubrics to suit the virtual format. Considerations include the use of digital platforms for essay submissions, incorporating multimedia elements, and adjusting assessment criteria to account for the unique challenges of online learning. Rubrics should be accessible to students in digital formats and clearly outline the expectations for their writing assignments. Educators may need to modify language or instructions to ensure clarity and ease of understanding in the online context.

In virtual classrooms, it’s crucial to maintain the authenticity and meaningfulness of essay writing assessment. Rubrics should align with the learning objectives and remain comprehensive in evaluating students’ writing skills and comprehension. Educators should avoid simply measuring surface-level aspects and, instead, emphasize deeper critical thinking, creativity, and effective communication in students’ essays. By using well-structured rubrics, educators can maintain high standards for assessment and provide constructive feedback that fosters continuous improvement in students’ writing abilities.

In remote learning environments, technology can streamline the grading process and enhance the efficiency of rubric-based assessment. Educators can use online grading tools that integrate rubrics, allowing for faster and more consistent evaluations. Some digital platforms also offer automated feedback, which can provide immediate insights to students, facilitating their learning process. Technology can also help in tracking student progress over time, identifying trends, and informing instructional adjustments to better support students’ needs.

By adapting rubrics for online essay assessments, ensuring authentic evaluation, and leveraging technology, educators can maintain the effectiveness of essay writing assessment in remote learning environments. Clear and comprehensive rubrics combined with thoughtful feedback promote student engagement and improvement, supporting students’ academic growth regardless of the learning setting.

In conclusion, implementing rubrics for essay writing assessment is a valuable and effective tool in promoting fair, consistent, and objective evaluation of students’ writing skills. Rubrics provide a clear framework for both educators and students, enhancing transparency and understanding of assessment expectations.

By defining criteria, levels of performance, and weighting, rubrics facilitate constructive feedback and support continuous improvement. Whether in traditional or remote learning environments, rubrics play a crucial role in aligning assessment with learning objectives and fostering meaningful student growth.

As educators continue to refine and adapt rubrics, they empower students to develop stronger writing abilities and succeed academically. The thoughtful use of rubrics contributes to a more equitable and enriching educational experience for all learners.

People Also Read

  • Essay Writing Assessment Rubrics: Understanding the 9 Importance in Writing
  • Understanding Essay Writing Assessment Criteria: A Comprehensive Guide
  • Essay Writing Self-Assessment: 7 Importance in Essay Writing

2 thoughts on “Rubrics for Essay Writing Assessment: A Comprehensive Guide”

Pingback: Essay Writing Techniques for Exams: Boost Your Exam Scores with These 10 Professional Tips

Pingback: Essay Writing Self-Assessment: 7 Importance in Essay Writing

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

  • Home div.mega__menu -->
  • Guiding Principles
  • Assessment Cycle
  • Equity in Assessment
  • FAQs About Assessment
  • Learning Outcomes & Evidence
  • Undergraduate Learning Goals & Outcomes
  • University Assessment Reports
  • Program Assessment Reports
  • University Survey Reports
  • Assessment in Action
  • Internal Assessment Grant
  • Celebrating Assessment at LMU
  • Assessment Advisory Committee
  • Workshops & Events
  • Assessment Resources
  • Recommended Websites
  • Recommended Books
  • Contact div.mega__menu -->

Creative Writing Example Rubric

Rubric is a modification of one presented by: University Community Links (n.d.). Hot writing rubric. Retrieved August 19, 2008 from http://www.uclinks.org/reference/evaluation/HOT.html

IMAGES

  1. 3 Types of Writing Rubrics for Effective Assessments

    assessment rubric for essay writing

  2. 020 Rubrics For Essay Example Writing High School English ~ Thatsnotus

    assessment rubric for essay writing

  3. 46 Editable Rubric Templates (Word Format) ᐅ TemplateLab

    assessment rubric for essay writing

  4. Writing Rubric Worksheet Examples

    assessment rubric for essay writing

  5. Two Customizable ESL Writing Rubric Templates

    assessment rubric for essay writing

  6. Formidable Rubrics In Essay Writing ~ Thatsnotus

    assessment rubric for essay writing

VIDEO

  1. 1 1b Introduction to Example Essay Question

  2. Essay Writing Rubric

  3. GUIDE TO WRITING AN ESSAY📝

  4. Rubric Assessment tool for ENAC 221 Major Assignment 1

COMMENTS

  1. PDF Writing Assessment and Evaluation Rubrics

    6 Writing Assessment and Evaluation Rubrics,Grade 9 ... For example, a student writing a personal essay needs to know that per-sonal essays express the writer's thoughts and opinions, often incorporate personal anecdotes or experiences, and are usually written in a less formal style than a literary

  2. PDF Writing Assessment and Evaluation Rubrics

    6 Writing Assessment and Evaluation Rubrics,Grade 11 ... For example, a student writing a personal essay needs to know that per-sonal essays express the writer's thoughts and opinions, often incorporate personal anecdotes or experiences, and are usually written in a less formal style than a literary

  3. Writing Rubrics: How to Score Well on Your Paper

    A writing rubric is a clear set of guidelines on what your paper should include, often written as a rating scale that shows the range of scores possible on the assignment and how to earn each one. Professors use writing rubrics to grade the essays they assign, typically scoring on content, organization, mechanics, and overall understanding.

  4. PDF Essay Rubric

    Essay Rubric Directions: Your essay will be graded based on this rubric. Consequently, use this rubric as a guide when writing your essay and check it again before you submit your essay.

  5. Rubric Design

    Writing rubrics can help address the concerns of both faculty and students by making writing assessment more efficient, consistent, and public. Whether it is called a grading rubric, a grading sheet, or a scoring guide, a writing assignment rubric lists criteria by which the writing is graded.

  6. Rubric Best Practices, Examples, and Templates

    A rubric is a scoring tool that identifies the different criteria relevant to an assignment, assessment, or learning outcome and states the possible levels of achievement in a specific, clear, and objective way. Use rubrics to assess project-based student work including essays, group projects, creative endeavors, and oral presentations.

  7. Sample Essay Rubric for Elementary Teachers

    An essay rubric is a way teachers assess students' essay writing by using specific criteria to grade assignments. Essay rubrics save teachers time because all of the criteria are listed and organized into one convenient paper. If used effectively, rubrics can help improve students' writing . How to Use an Essay Rubric

  8. Essay Rubric

    Home Classroom Resources Printouts Assessment Tool Essay Rubric Grades 6 - 12 Printout Type Assessment Tool View Printout About this printout This rubric delineates specific expectations about an essay assignment to students and provides a means of assessing completed student essays. Teaching with this printout More ideas to try

  9. PDF Writing Assessment and Evaluation Rubrics

    6 Writing Assessment and Evaluation Rubrics,Grade 12 ... For example, a student writing a personal essay needs to know that per-sonal essays express the writer's thoughts and opinions, often incorporate personal anecdotes or experiences, and are usually written in a less formal style than a literary

  10. Academic essay rubric

    Academic essay rubric This is a grading rubric an instructor uses to assess students' work on this type of assignment. It is a sample rubric that needs to be edited to reflect the specifics of a particular assignment. Download this file Loading… Download this file [63.33 KB] Back to Resources Page

  11. PDF Argumentative essay rubric

    Arrangement of essay is unclear and illogical. The writing lacks a clear sense of direction. Ideas, details or events seem strung together in a loose or random fashion; there is no identifiable internal structure and readers have trouble following the writer's line of thought. Few, forced transitions in the essay or no transitions are present.

  12. Assessment Rubrics

    Assessment Rubrics A rubric is commonly defined as a tool that articulates the expectations for an assignment by listing criteria, and for each criteria, describing levels of quality (Andrade, 2000; Arter & Chappuis, 2007; Stiggins, 2001). Criteria are used in determining the level at which student work meets expectations.

  13. Rubrics

    Rubrics are tools for communicating grading criteria and assessing student progress. Rubrics take a variety of forms, from grids to checklists, and measure a range of writing tasks, from conceptual design to sentence-level considerations.

  14. Creating and Using Rubrics

    Step 6: Discuss with colleagues. Review feedback and revise. Important: When developing a rubric for program assessment, enlist the help of colleagues. Rubrics promote shared expectations and consistent grading practices which benefit faculty members and students in the program. 5.

  15. PDF Assessing writing for Cambridge English Qualifications: A guide for

    1. Writing Assessment Scale 2. Writing Assessment subscales 1. Assessment criteria 2. Assessment categories Each piece of writing gets four sets of marks for each of the subscales, from 0 (lowest) to 5 (highest). Bands (0-5) marks / scores / grades These terms are commonly used to refer to Cambridge English Qualifications. There are also some

  16. 15 Helpful Scoring Rubric Examples for All Grades and Subjects

    Jun 16, 2023 When it comes to student assessment and evaluation, there are a lot of methods to consider. In some cases, testing is the best way to assess a student's knowledge, and the answers are either right or wrong. But often, assessing a student's performance is much less clear-cut.

  17. PDF B2 First for Schools

    1. Writing Assessment Scale 2. Writing Assessment subscales 1. Assessment criteria 2. Assessment categories Each piece of writing gets four sets of marks for each of the subscales, from 0 (lowest) to 5 (highest). Bands (0-5) marks / scores / grades These terms are commonly used to refer to Cambridge English Qualifications. There are also some

  18. 3 Types of Writing Rubrics for Effective Assessments

    3 Types of Writing Rubrics for Effective Assessments There are so many different writing rubrics out there and it may be difficult to find the right one. Below you will find a guide with 3 types of effective writing rubrics. Choosing the right one depends on the writing genre and your needs for the assessment. Student-Friendly Rubrics

  19. Rubrics for Essay Writing Assessment: A Comprehensive Guide

    An effective rubric for essay writing assessment includes a clear identification of key criteria that reflect the essential elements of a well-written essay. These criteria typically encompass various aspects of the essay, such as content, organization, language, mechanics, and argumentation.

  20. Creative Writing Example Rubric

    Creative Writing Example Rubric. Students will write well organized, cohesive papers. Work functions well as a whole. Piece has a clear flow and a sense of purpose. Response has either a strong lead, developed body, or satisfying conclusion, but not all three. Uneven. Awkward or missing transitions. Weakly unified.

  21. Writing Assessments

    Writing will be computer-based in all assessed grades, and prompts will be in response to texts. Writing Resources 2023-24 B.E.S.T. Writing Fact Sheet (PDF) B.E.S.T. Writing Rubrics Grades 4-6 Argumentative (PDF) Grades 4-6 Expository (PDF) Grades 7-10 Argumentative (PDF) Grades 7-10 Expository (PDF) B.E.S.T. Writing Scoring Samplers

  22. English CAPS Document

    Each student is marked on the following elements given in the English CAPS document for essay writing skills: Introduction and conclusion. Body. Organisation and style. Spelling, vocabulary and punctuation. Creativity. For each of these elements, a mark of 1-4 is given (1 being poor and 4 being excellent). This adds up to the overall score for ...